The Assay · 21 October 2026

Can your business run without you? Three tests to run this month

Good results tell you how the business performs with you in it. They say nothing about how it performs without you, and I think for years the two can move in opposite directions.

A contractor wrote on a small-business forum that he makes good money. There is work all year round, for him and for his employees.

“But without me it doesn’t run smooth.” He is the foreman, the project manager and the estimator. “It’s exhausting and difficult.”

Then the two sentences that matter. “With me the business profits 200k or more a year. Without me who knows.”

He knows the first number. The second he doesn’t know.

Your business may be bigger than his and your management accounts better. Having managers doesn’t settle it. A business with a finance director and a contracts manager can still have the decisions that matter waiting on one desk. Ask yourself his question anyway. What does the business make without you?

Better results and more dependence can grow together

A good year feels like proof that the business works. Often it is proof that you worked. More customers, more quotes, more decisions. More of them land on your desk, because you are quick and nobody minds waiting for you.

The accounts record the result. They don’t record who it ran through. A business too dependent on the owner can look healthy on every page of the management accounts.

The contractor’s two sentences are, in effect, the method in a valuation textbook by Aswath Damodaran. It says to value a business that relies on a key person twice: once as it is, and again with that person’s loss built into the revenues, earnings and cash flows. The gap between the two is what the person is worth to the business.

You have the first figure. The second tells you whether the good years made the business stronger, or just made you busier.

Neha Kabra, writing about companies owned by private equity firms, sets out how a buyer judges it: “Buyers test whether performance transfers.”

Her signals include procedures that are written down, people below the top team who own the numbers, and a management routine that doesn’t need the private equity owner in the room. If performance sits with two or three people and that owner’s oversight, she writes, “a buyer prices that dependency.”

The companies she writes about are owned by private equity firms, not founders. The test carries across. It is the same question as whether you could take a fortnight off without the phone, or be ill for a month, and come back to a business that had run. I have taken three of her signals, and part of a fourth, and put them in an owner’s words.

Test one: a written procedure someone else has used

Not whether a procedure exists. Whether someone other than you has followed it in the last year, on a job that mattered.

Pick the procedure that carries the most money: taking on a new customer, ordering for a large job, closing the month. When did someone else last open it and use it without ringing you? If you had been away, where would they have looked?

A folder of procedures nobody opens is the same as no procedures. Earlier issues, The System of Record in Your Head and Everybody Knows the Process, covered the gap between what is written down and how the work is actually decided.

Test two: numbers owned by someone below you

Take the five numbers you look at every month. Sales, margin, cash, the order book, whatever yours are. When one of them moves, who explains it? If the answer for four of the five is you, your managers report the numbers. You own them.

Then the harder version. Which calls does nobody else make? Not can’t. Doesn’t. A price change, a hire, a concession to an unhappy customer. Count the ones in the last two months that waited for you.

Test three: a monthly meeting that decides without you

When you are away, does the management meeting happen? Does it decide anything? Or does it collect questions for when you are back?

The Ten-Day Test suggested staying out of the business for ten working days, with a list written beforehand of what you expect will wait for you. This is the smaller version. Miss one meeting on purpose. When you are back, ask what was decided and who decided it.

Read the three answers together. A procedure nobody else has used, four numbers in five that come back to you, a meeting that waits for your return: I would read that as a business whose good years were built on you. If all three come back that way, the results and the dependence have been growing together.

Why someone outside sees it more clearly

You can run these three tests yourself, this month, without hiring anyone. You are still the worst-placed person to mark them. Not because you are careless. Every answer runs through you, so from where you sit the business works.

Each test has a blind spot from your chair. The decisions that waited for you never felt like waiting; they felt like a normal week. Ask a manager who explains the margin and, with you asking, the answer is them. Miss a meeting and everyone in it knows you will hear what was decided.

An outsider who asks without knowing the answers, and who won’t accept “they’d manage”, comes back with figures where you have impressions: rules someone else has used, numbers owned below you, decisions made without you. That might be a fractional CFO or an adviser. What matters is that they count.

Counting, not asking, is how I would mark them. It counts the dependence. It does not value the business.

You know what the business makes with you. The other number is the one worth having while you can still change it.

Sources: https://www.reddit.com/r/smallbusiness/comments/1j1g0jv/comment/mfjls4i/ (a contractor’s reply on a small-business forum, March 2025); Aswath Damodaran, Investment Valuation, University Edition, 4th edition, Wiley, 2025, chapter 24 (Valuing Private Firms: the key person effect on value); Neha Kabra, “Private Equity: From IC Thesis to Exit Proof. How GPs Build Exit-Ready Portfolios”, May 2026: https://nehakabra1.substack.com/p/private-equity-from-ic-thesis-to

Previously in The Assay: Not ready to step back from your business? The two questions in 'not yet'

The Assay is written by Rudi Prenzlin at Scalable Growth, a UK practice that gives owner-managed businesses a fractional CFO and the operational structure to run without every decision going through the owner.

← All notes Begin a conversation